Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joshua Derrick's avatar

Lost me at seed oils. This has been extensively debunked. https://web.archive.org/web/20220425214028/https://www.the-nutrivore.com/post/a-comprehensive-rebuttal-to-seed-oil-sophistry. Even without reading the extensive analysis of the literature, which suggests that replacement of saturated fats with PUFAs improves health outcomes, the argument on its face is ridiculous. You claim that PUFA, and PUFA oxidation are the things that are killing us, and this is only happening now because seed oils are new phenomena. This could not be further from the truth. We've used olive oil for almost all of recorded history, which is also composed of mostly oleic and linoleic acid. Only the second is technically a PUFA, and is present in roughly the same proportions in Canola and Olive Oil.

You also lost me on the animal protein. Animal protein has extensively been shown to correlate with decreased lifespan, possibly because it's highly correlated with saturated fat intake, but also because those BCAAs that are so good for muscle development also trigger inflammation, development of coronary artery disease, and premature cancers.

The 7-country study (and the 7th day adventist study which is perhaps even better) done by Ancel Keys and colleagues definitely shows that the mediterranean diet, which is rich in polyunsaturated fats, fiber, and vegetables (but importantly not excluding fish, eggs, or dairy) produces the best health outcomes, better than vegan diets, and certainly far better than the ticket to heart disease you seem to be promising here.

I loved your sleep article but you gotta do better here. This article is a bunch of crap.

Expand full comment
Bart Bounds's avatar

Good stuff.

Over decades this is (more or less) what I have come to instinctively.

Once one’s food/body relationship is good, one just eats what is ‘right’.

For me, eat ‘as far back in time’ as you can. I thrive the more I can eat wild game/fish/forage. The process of obtaining this type of food is healthy too!

Expand full comment
45 more comments...

No posts